Files
breakpilot-compliance/backend-compliance/compliance/services/batch_dedup_runner.py
Benjamin Admin 770f0b5ab0
All checks were successful
CI/CD / go-lint (push) Has been skipped
CI/CD / python-lint (push) Has been skipped
CI/CD / nodejs-lint (push) Has been skipped
CI/CD / test-go-ai-compliance (push) Successful in 31s
CI/CD / test-python-backend-compliance (push) Successful in 31s
CI/CD / test-python-document-crawler (push) Successful in 21s
CI/CD / test-python-dsms-gateway (push) Successful in 19s
CI/CD / validate-canonical-controls (push) Successful in 10s
CI/CD / Deploy (push) Successful in 2s
fix: adapt batch dedup to NULL pattern_id — group by merge_group_hint
All Pass 0b controls have pattern_id=NULL. Rewritten to:
- Phase 1: Group by merge_group_hint (action:object:trigger), 52k groups
- Phase 2: Cross-group embedding search for semantically similar masters
- Qdrant search uses unfiltered cross-regulation endpoint
- API param changed: pattern_id → hint_filter

Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.6 <noreply@anthropic.com>
2026-03-24 07:24:02 +01:00

592 lines
23 KiB
Python

"""Batch Dedup Runner — Orchestrates deduplication of ~85k atomare Controls.
Reduces Pass 0b controls from ~85k to ~18-25k unique Master Controls via:
Phase 1: Intra-Group Dedup — same merge_group_hint → pick best, link rest
(85k → ~52k, mostly title-identical short-circuit, no embeddings)
Phase 2: Cross-Group Dedup — embed masters, search Qdrant for similar
masters with different hints (52k → ~18-25k)
All Pass 0b controls have pattern_id=NULL. The primary grouping key is
merge_group_hint (format: "action_type:norm_obj:trigger_key"), which
encodes the normalized action, object, and trigger.
Usage:
runner = BatchDedupRunner(db)
stats = await runner.run(dry_run=True) # preview
stats = await runner.run(dry_run=False) # execute
stats = await runner.run(hint_filter="implement:multi_factor_auth:none")
"""
import json
import logging
import time
from collections import defaultdict
from sqlalchemy import text
from compliance.services.control_dedup import (
canonicalize_text,
ensure_qdrant_collection,
get_embedding,
normalize_action,
normalize_object,
qdrant_search_cross_regulation,
qdrant_upsert,
LINK_THRESHOLD,
REVIEW_THRESHOLD,
)
logger = logging.getLogger(__name__)
DEDUP_COLLECTION = "atomic_controls_dedup"
# ── Quality Score ────────────────────────────────────────────────────────
def quality_score(control: dict) -> float:
"""Score a control by richness of requirements, tests, evidence, and objective.
Higher score = better candidate for master control.
"""
score = 0.0
reqs = control.get("requirements") or "[]"
if isinstance(reqs, str):
try:
reqs = json.loads(reqs)
except (json.JSONDecodeError, TypeError):
reqs = []
score += len(reqs) * 2.0
tests = control.get("test_procedure") or "[]"
if isinstance(tests, str):
try:
tests = json.loads(tests)
except (json.JSONDecodeError, TypeError):
tests = []
score += len(tests) * 1.5
evidence = control.get("evidence") or "[]"
if isinstance(evidence, str):
try:
evidence = json.loads(evidence)
except (json.JSONDecodeError, TypeError):
evidence = []
score += len(evidence) * 1.0
objective = control.get("objective") or ""
score += min(len(objective) / 200, 3.0)
return score
# ── Batch Dedup Runner ───────────────────────────────────────────────────
class BatchDedupRunner:
"""Batch dedup orchestrator for existing Pass 0b atomic controls."""
def __init__(self, db, collection: str = DEDUP_COLLECTION):
self.db = db
self.collection = collection
self.stats = {
"total_controls": 0,
"unique_hints": 0,
"phase1_groups_processed": 0,
"masters": 0,
"linked": 0,
"review": 0,
"new_controls": 0,
"parent_links_transferred": 0,
"cross_group_linked": 0,
"cross_group_review": 0,
"errors": 0,
"skipped_title_identical": 0,
}
self._progress_phase = ""
self._progress_count = 0
self._progress_total = 0
async def run(
self,
dry_run: bool = False,
hint_filter: str = None,
) -> dict:
"""Run the full batch dedup pipeline.
Args:
dry_run: If True, compute stats but don't modify DB/Qdrant.
hint_filter: If set, only process groups matching this hint prefix.
Returns:
Stats dict with counts.
"""
start = time.monotonic()
logger.info("BatchDedup starting (dry_run=%s, hint_filter=%s)",
dry_run, hint_filter)
if not dry_run:
await ensure_qdrant_collection(collection=self.collection)
# Phase 1: Intra-group dedup (same merge_group_hint)
self._progress_phase = "phase1"
groups = self._load_merge_groups(hint_filter)
self._progress_total = self.stats["total_controls"]
for hint, controls in groups:
try:
await self._process_hint_group(hint, controls, dry_run)
self.stats["phase1_groups_processed"] += 1
except Exception as e:
logger.error("BatchDedup Phase 1 error on hint %s: %s", hint, e)
self.stats["errors"] += 1
logger.info(
"BatchDedup Phase 1 done: %d masters, %d linked, %d review",
self.stats["masters"], self.stats["linked"], self.stats["review"],
)
# Phase 2: Cross-group dedup via embeddings
if not dry_run:
self._progress_phase = "phase2"
await self._run_cross_group_pass()
elapsed = time.monotonic() - start
self.stats["elapsed_seconds"] = round(elapsed, 1)
logger.info("BatchDedup completed in %.1fs: %s", elapsed, self.stats)
return self.stats
def _load_merge_groups(self, hint_filter: str = None) -> list:
"""Load all Pass 0b controls grouped by merge_group_hint, largest first."""
conditions = [
"decomposition_method = 'pass0b'",
"release_state != 'deprecated'",
"release_state != 'duplicate'",
]
params = {}
if hint_filter:
conditions.append("generation_metadata->>'merge_group_hint' LIKE :hf")
params["hf"] = f"{hint_filter}%"
where = " AND ".join(conditions)
rows = self.db.execute(text(f"""
SELECT id::text, control_id, title, objective,
pattern_id, requirements::text, test_procedure::text,
evidence::text, release_state,
generation_metadata->>'merge_group_hint' as merge_group_hint,
generation_metadata->>'action_object_class' as action_object_class
FROM canonical_controls
WHERE {where}
ORDER BY control_id
"""), params).fetchall()
by_hint = defaultdict(list)
for r in rows:
by_hint[r[9] or ""].append({
"uuid": r[0],
"control_id": r[1],
"title": r[2],
"objective": r[3],
"pattern_id": r[4],
"requirements": r[5],
"test_procedure": r[6],
"evidence": r[7],
"release_state": r[8],
"merge_group_hint": r[9] or "",
"action_object_class": r[10] or "",
})
self.stats["total_controls"] = len(rows)
self.stats["unique_hints"] = len(by_hint)
sorted_groups = sorted(by_hint.items(), key=lambda x: len(x[1]), reverse=True)
logger.info("BatchDedup loaded %d controls in %d hint groups",
len(rows), len(sorted_groups))
return sorted_groups
def _sub_group_by_merge_hint(self, controls: list) -> dict:
"""Group controls by merge_group_hint composite key."""
groups = defaultdict(list)
for c in controls:
hint = c["merge_group_hint"]
if hint:
groups[hint].append(c)
else:
groups[f"__no_hint_{c['uuid']}"].append(c)
return dict(groups)
async def _process_hint_group(
self,
hint: str,
controls: list,
dry_run: bool,
):
"""Process all controls sharing the same merge_group_hint.
Within a hint group, all controls share action+object+trigger.
The best-quality control becomes master, rest are linked as duplicates.
"""
if len(controls) < 2:
# Singleton → always master
self.stats["masters"] += 1
if not dry_run:
await self._embed_and_index(controls[0])
self._progress_count += 1
self._log_progress(hint)
return
# Sort by quality score (best first)
sorted_group = sorted(controls, key=quality_score, reverse=True)
master = sorted_group[0]
self.stats["masters"] += 1
if not dry_run:
await self._embed_and_index(master)
for candidate in sorted_group[1:]:
# All share the same hint → check title similarity
if candidate["title"].strip().lower() == master["title"].strip().lower():
# Identical title → direct link (no embedding needed)
self.stats["linked"] += 1
self.stats["skipped_title_identical"] += 1
if not dry_run:
await self._mark_duplicate(master, candidate, confidence=1.0)
else:
# Different title within same hint → still likely duplicate
# Use embedding to verify
await self._check_and_link_within_group(master, candidate, dry_run)
self._progress_count += 1
self._log_progress(hint)
async def _check_and_link_within_group(
self,
master: dict,
candidate: dict,
dry_run: bool,
):
"""Check if candidate (same hint group) is duplicate of master via embedding."""
parts = candidate["merge_group_hint"].split(":", 2)
action = parts[0] if len(parts) > 0 else ""
obj = parts[1] if len(parts) > 1 else ""
canonical = canonicalize_text(action, obj, candidate["title"])
embedding = await get_embedding(canonical)
if not embedding:
# Can't embed → link anyway (same hint = same action+object)
self.stats["linked"] += 1
if not dry_run:
await self._mark_duplicate(master, candidate, confidence=0.90)
return
# Search the dedup collection (unfiltered — pattern_id is NULL)
results = await qdrant_search_cross_regulation(
embedding, top_k=3, collection=self.collection,
)
if not results:
# No Qdrant matches yet (master might not be indexed yet) → link to master
self.stats["linked"] += 1
if not dry_run:
await self._mark_duplicate(master, candidate, confidence=0.90)
return
best = results[0]
best_score = best.get("score", 0.0)
best_payload = best.get("payload", {})
best_uuid = best_payload.get("control_uuid", "")
if best_score > LINK_THRESHOLD:
self.stats["linked"] += 1
if not dry_run:
await self._mark_duplicate_to(best_uuid, candidate, confidence=best_score)
elif best_score > REVIEW_THRESHOLD:
self.stats["review"] += 1
if not dry_run:
self._write_review(candidate, best_payload, best_score)
else:
# Very different despite same hint → new master
self.stats["new_controls"] += 1
if not dry_run:
await self._index_with_embedding(candidate, embedding)
async def _run_cross_group_pass(self):
"""Phase 2: Find cross-group duplicates among surviving masters.
After Phase 1, ~52k masters remain. Many have similar semantics
despite different merge_group_hints (e.g. different German spellings).
This pass embeds all masters and finds near-duplicates via Qdrant.
"""
logger.info("BatchDedup Phase 2: Cross-group pass starting...")
rows = self.db.execute(text("""
SELECT id::text, control_id, title,
generation_metadata->>'merge_group_hint' as merge_group_hint
FROM canonical_controls
WHERE decomposition_method = 'pass0b'
AND release_state != 'duplicate'
AND release_state != 'deprecated'
ORDER BY control_id
""")).fetchall()
self._progress_total = len(rows)
self._progress_count = 0
logger.info("BatchDedup Cross-group: %d masters to check", len(rows))
cross_linked = 0
cross_review = 0
for i, r in enumerate(rows):
uuid = r[0]
hint = r[3] or ""
parts = hint.split(":", 2)
action = parts[0] if len(parts) > 0 else ""
obj = parts[1] if len(parts) > 1 else ""
canonical = canonicalize_text(action, obj, r[2])
embedding = await get_embedding(canonical)
if not embedding:
continue
results = await qdrant_search_cross_regulation(
embedding, top_k=5, collection=self.collection,
)
if not results:
continue
# Find best match from a DIFFERENT hint group
for match in results:
match_score = match.get("score", 0.0)
match_payload = match.get("payload", {})
match_uuid = match_payload.get("control_uuid", "")
# Skip self-match
if match_uuid == uuid:
continue
# Must be a different hint group (otherwise already handled in Phase 1)
match_action = match_payload.get("action_normalized", "")
match_object = match_payload.get("object_normalized", "")
# Simple check: different control UUID is enough
if match_score > LINK_THRESHOLD:
# Mark the worse one as duplicate
self.db.execute(text("""
UPDATE canonical_controls
SET release_state = 'duplicate', merged_into_uuid = CAST(:master AS uuid)
WHERE id = CAST(:dup AS uuid)
AND release_state != 'duplicate'
"""), {"master": match_uuid, "dup": uuid})
self.db.execute(text("""
INSERT INTO control_parent_links
(control_uuid, parent_control_uuid, link_type, confidence)
VALUES (CAST(:cu AS uuid), CAST(:pu AS uuid), 'cross_regulation', :conf)
ON CONFLICT (control_uuid, parent_control_uuid) DO NOTHING
"""), {"cu": match_uuid, "pu": uuid, "conf": match_score})
# Transfer parent links
transferred = self._transfer_parent_links(match_uuid, uuid)
self.stats["parent_links_transferred"] += transferred
self.db.commit()
cross_linked += 1
break # Only one cross-link per control
elif match_score > REVIEW_THRESHOLD:
self._write_review(
{"control_id": r[1], "title": r[2], "objective": "",
"merge_group_hint": hint, "pattern_id": None},
match_payload, match_score,
)
cross_review += 1
break
self._progress_count = i + 1
if (i + 1) % 500 == 0:
logger.info("BatchDedup Cross-group: %d/%d checked, %d linked, %d review",
i + 1, len(rows), cross_linked, cross_review)
self.stats["cross_group_linked"] = cross_linked
self.stats["cross_group_review"] = cross_review
logger.info("BatchDedup Cross-group complete: %d linked, %d review",
cross_linked, cross_review)
# ── Qdrant Helpers ───────────────────────────────────────────────────
async def _embed_and_index(self, control: dict):
"""Compute embedding and index a control in the dedup Qdrant collection."""
parts = control["merge_group_hint"].split(":", 2)
action = parts[0] if len(parts) > 0 else ""
obj = parts[1] if len(parts) > 1 else ""
norm_action = normalize_action(action)
norm_object = normalize_object(obj)
canonical = canonicalize_text(action, obj, control["title"])
embedding = await get_embedding(canonical)
if not embedding:
return
await qdrant_upsert(
point_id=control["uuid"],
embedding=embedding,
payload={
"control_uuid": control["uuid"],
"control_id": control["control_id"],
"title": control["title"],
"pattern_id": control.get("pattern_id"),
"action_normalized": norm_action,
"object_normalized": norm_object,
"canonical_text": canonical,
"merge_group_hint": control["merge_group_hint"],
},
collection=self.collection,
)
async def _index_with_embedding(self, control: dict, embedding: list):
"""Index a control with a pre-computed embedding."""
parts = control["merge_group_hint"].split(":", 2)
action = parts[0] if len(parts) > 0 else ""
obj = parts[1] if len(parts) > 1 else ""
norm_action = normalize_action(action)
norm_object = normalize_object(obj)
canonical = canonicalize_text(action, obj, control["title"])
await qdrant_upsert(
point_id=control["uuid"],
embedding=embedding,
payload={
"control_uuid": control["uuid"],
"control_id": control["control_id"],
"title": control["title"],
"pattern_id": control.get("pattern_id"),
"action_normalized": norm_action,
"object_normalized": norm_object,
"canonical_text": canonical,
"merge_group_hint": control["merge_group_hint"],
},
collection=self.collection,
)
# ── DB Write Helpers ─────────────────────────────────────────────────
async def _mark_duplicate(self, master: dict, candidate: dict, confidence: float):
"""Mark candidate as duplicate of master, transfer parent links."""
self.db.execute(text("""
UPDATE canonical_controls
SET release_state = 'duplicate', merged_into_uuid = CAST(:master AS uuid)
WHERE id = CAST(:cand AS uuid)
"""), {"master": master["uuid"], "cand": candidate["uuid"]})
self.db.execute(text("""
INSERT INTO control_parent_links
(control_uuid, parent_control_uuid, link_type, confidence)
VALUES (CAST(:master AS uuid), CAST(:cand_parent AS uuid), 'dedup_merge', :conf)
ON CONFLICT (control_uuid, parent_control_uuid) DO NOTHING
"""), {"master": master["uuid"], "cand_parent": candidate["uuid"], "conf": confidence})
transferred = self._transfer_parent_links(master["uuid"], candidate["uuid"])
self.stats["parent_links_transferred"] += transferred
self.db.commit()
async def _mark_duplicate_to(self, master_uuid: str, candidate: dict, confidence: float):
"""Mark candidate as duplicate of a Qdrant-matched master."""
self.db.execute(text("""
UPDATE canonical_controls
SET release_state = 'duplicate', merged_into_uuid = CAST(:master AS uuid)
WHERE id = CAST(:cand AS uuid)
"""), {"master": master_uuid, "cand": candidate["uuid"]})
self.db.execute(text("""
INSERT INTO control_parent_links
(control_uuid, parent_control_uuid, link_type, confidence)
VALUES (CAST(:master AS uuid), CAST(:cand_parent AS uuid), 'dedup_merge', :conf)
ON CONFLICT (control_uuid, parent_control_uuid) DO NOTHING
"""), {"master": master_uuid, "cand_parent": candidate["uuid"], "conf": confidence})
transferred = self._transfer_parent_links(master_uuid, candidate["uuid"])
self.stats["parent_links_transferred"] += transferred
self.db.commit()
def _transfer_parent_links(self, master_uuid: str, duplicate_uuid: str) -> int:
"""Move existing parent links from duplicate to master."""
rows = self.db.execute(text("""
SELECT parent_control_uuid::text, link_type, confidence,
source_regulation, source_article, obligation_candidate_id::text
FROM control_parent_links
WHERE control_uuid = CAST(:dup AS uuid)
AND link_type = 'decomposition'
"""), {"dup": duplicate_uuid}).fetchall()
transferred = 0
for r in rows:
parent_uuid = r[0]
if parent_uuid == master_uuid:
continue
self.db.execute(text("""
INSERT INTO control_parent_links
(control_uuid, parent_control_uuid, link_type, confidence,
source_regulation, source_article, obligation_candidate_id)
VALUES (CAST(:cu AS uuid), CAST(:pu AS uuid), :lt, :conf,
:sr, :sa, CAST(:oci AS uuid))
ON CONFLICT (control_uuid, parent_control_uuid) DO NOTHING
"""), {
"cu": master_uuid,
"pu": parent_uuid,
"lt": r[1],
"conf": float(r[2]) if r[2] else 1.0,
"sr": r[3],
"sa": r[4],
"oci": r[5],
})
transferred += 1
return transferred
def _write_review(self, candidate: dict, matched_payload: dict, score: float):
"""Write a dedup review entry for borderline matches."""
self.db.execute(text("""
INSERT INTO control_dedup_reviews
(candidate_control_id, candidate_title, candidate_objective,
matched_control_uuid, matched_control_id,
similarity_score, dedup_stage, dedup_details)
VALUES (:ccid, :ct, :co, CAST(:mcu AS uuid), :mci,
:ss, 'batch_dedup', :dd::jsonb)
"""), {
"ccid": candidate["control_id"],
"ct": candidate["title"],
"co": candidate.get("objective", ""),
"mcu": matched_payload.get("control_uuid"),
"mci": matched_payload.get("control_id"),
"ss": score,
"dd": json.dumps({
"merge_group_hint": candidate.get("merge_group_hint", ""),
"pattern_id": candidate.get("pattern_id"),
}),
})
self.db.commit()
# ── Progress ─────────────────────────────────────────────────────────
def _log_progress(self, hint: str):
"""Log progress every 500 controls."""
if self._progress_count > 0 and self._progress_count % 500 == 0:
logger.info(
"BatchDedup [%s] %d/%d — masters=%d, linked=%d, review=%d",
self._progress_phase, self._progress_count, self._progress_total,
self.stats["masters"], self.stats["linked"], self.stats["review"],
)
def get_status(self) -> dict:
"""Return current progress stats (for status endpoint)."""
return {
"phase": self._progress_phase,
"progress": self._progress_count,
"total": self._progress_total,
**self.stats,
}