62fafaaec5
3-Tier-MaschinenVO-Verdict (direkt / sicherheitsrelevant / nicht relevant) aus Personengefährdungs-Signal: eine Komponente ist keine Maschine, aber wenn ihre Funktion bei Fehler ODER Manipulation Personen gefaehrden kann (Bewegung, Laser/ Auge, Kraft, Temperatur, elektrisch), ist sie sicherheitsrelevant — Pflicht trifft den Maschinenbauer, Zulieferer liefert Nachweise, und ein Cyber-Angriff kann die Sicherheitsfunktion aushebeln (Cyber-Safety-Bruecke). OWIS-mit-Laser landet so korrekt als 'sicherheitsrelevante Komponente'. Engine + /readiness additiv; Frontend: Gefährdungs-Frage + -Typen, MaschinenVO-Ergebnisblock. Presets aktualisiert (OWIS: Laser+Bewegung, Zwick: Bewegung). 22 Tests gruen. Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.7 <noreply@anthropic.com>
170 lines
7.4 KiB
Python
170 lines
7.4 KiB
Python
"""Neutral CRA applicability verdict for the 'Eingangstür' readiness check.
|
||
|
||
Separates LEGAL obligation from MARKET pull — the distinction SME manufacturers
|
||
actually care about: a product may not yet be legally in CRA scope, but its B2B
|
||
customers (machine/plant builders) will demand CRA evidence anyway.
|
||
|
||
Key rule: not the development date but the PLACING ON THE MARKET (Inverkehrbringen)
|
||
decides. A legacy product (e.g. designed 2019) still placed on the market after
|
||
the CRA cutoff must be conformant.
|
||
|
||
Pure + deterministic: no DB, no LLM, no network. Reuses the existing Annex III/IV
|
||
classifier (passed in as `cra_class`) — this is the verdict layer on top, not a
|
||
fourth classifier.
|
||
"""
|
||
|
||
CRA_CUTOFF = "2027-12-11" # CRA main obligations apply to products placed on the market from here
|
||
|
||
# Verdict tiers
|
||
ZWINGEND = "zwingend"
|
||
RATSAM = "ratsam"
|
||
NICHT_BETROFFEN = "nicht_betroffen"
|
||
|
||
_TIER_LABEL = {
|
||
ZWINGEND: "CRA zwingend (Rechtspflicht)",
|
||
RATSAM: "CRA nicht zwingend, aber dringend ratsam",
|
||
NICHT_BETROFFEN: "CRA nicht betroffen",
|
||
}
|
||
|
||
# Producer archetypes — drive default assumptions + verdict emphasis.
|
||
COMPONENT = "component" # Zulieferteil/Komponente (B2B), z. B. OWIS PS90+
|
||
END_DEVICE = "end_device" # Endgerät
|
||
MACHINE_INTEGRATOR = "machine_integrator" # Anlagen-/Maschinenbauer — Internet/OTA meist gegeben
|
||
SOFTWARE_APP = "software_app" # App/Frontend/Cloud, keine Hardware
|
||
PRODUCER_TYPES = (COMPONENT, END_DEVICE, MACHINE_INTEGRATOR, SOFTWARE_APP)
|
||
|
||
# Standard CRA evidence the cyber technical file needs (Annex I/II + Art. 13/14).
|
||
EVIDENCE_ITEMS = [
|
||
{"key": "sbom", "label": "Software-Stückliste (SBOM)"},
|
||
{"key": "vdp", "label": "Vulnerability-Disclosure-Policy / Security-Kontakt"},
|
||
{"key": "patch_process", "label": "Patch-/Update-Prozess (signiert)"},
|
||
{"key": "support_lifecycle", "label": "Support-Zeitraum / Lifecycle-Zusage"},
|
||
{"key": "threat_model", "label": "Threat Model / Cyber-Risikobeurteilung"},
|
||
{"key": "security_logging", "label": "Security-Logging"},
|
||
{"key": "auth_concept", "label": "Authentisierung / Passwortkonzept (Netzwerk)"},
|
||
{"key": "incident_process", "label": "Incident-/Meldeprozess (Art. 14, 24/72h)"},
|
||
]
|
||
_EVIDENCE_KEYS = {e["key"] for e in EVIDENCE_ITEMS}
|
||
|
||
|
||
def in_scope(cra_class: str) -> bool:
|
||
"""A product is in CRA scope once it has any digital element / Annex match."""
|
||
return (cra_class or "").upper() not in ("", "NOT_IN_SCOPE")
|
||
|
||
|
||
def compute_verdict(
|
||
cra_class: str,
|
||
placed_on_market_after_cutoff,
|
||
producer_type: str = "",
|
||
customers_request: bool = False,
|
||
) -> dict:
|
||
"""Neutral 3-tier verdict. `placed_on_market_after_cutoff`: True/False/None
|
||
(None = unknown → assumed True, conservative: most products keep being sold)."""
|
||
scope = in_scope(cra_class)
|
||
after_cutoff = True if placed_on_market_after_cutoff is None else bool(placed_on_market_after_cutoff)
|
||
# Components are inherently subject to downstream demand even absent an explicit signal.
|
||
market_pull = bool(customers_request) or producer_type == COMPONENT
|
||
|
||
reasons: list = []
|
||
if not scope:
|
||
tier = NICHT_BETROFFEN
|
||
reasons.append("Keine digitalen Elemente / keine CRA-Kategorie erkannt.")
|
||
if market_pull:
|
||
reasons.append("Hinweis: Kunden könnten dennoch CRA-Nachweise anfragen.")
|
||
elif after_cutoff:
|
||
tier = ZWINGEND
|
||
reasons.append(
|
||
f"Produkt mit digitalen Elementen und Inverkehrbringen ab {CRA_CUTOFF} → Rechtspflicht."
|
||
)
|
||
reasons.append("Maßgeblich ist das Inverkehrbringen, nicht der Entwicklungszeitpunkt.")
|
||
else:
|
||
tier = RATSAM
|
||
reasons.append("Produkt mit digitalen Elementen, aber kein Inverkehrbringen im CRA-Geltungszeitraum.")
|
||
reasons.append(f"Sobald ab dem {CRA_CUTOFF} (weiter) in Verkehr gebracht wird, wird CRA zwingend.")
|
||
|
||
if market_pull and tier != NICHT_BETROFFEN:
|
||
reasons.append("Markt-Druck: B2B-Kunden (Maschinen-/Anlagenbauer) fordern CRA-Nachweise zur Komponente.")
|
||
|
||
return {
|
||
"tier": tier,
|
||
"label": _TIER_LABEL[tier],
|
||
"in_scope": scope,
|
||
"market_pull": market_pull,
|
||
"cra_class": (cra_class or "").upper(),
|
||
"cutoff": CRA_CUTOFF,
|
||
"placed_on_market_after_cutoff": after_cutoff,
|
||
"reasons": reasons,
|
||
}
|
||
|
||
|
||
def maturity(provided_evidence_keys) -> dict:
|
||
"""Reifegrad over the standard CRA evidence checklist."""
|
||
have = {k for k in (provided_evidence_keys or []) if k in _EVIDENCE_KEYS}
|
||
present = [e for e in EVIDENCE_ITEMS if e["key"] in have]
|
||
missing = [e for e in EVIDENCE_ITEMS if e["key"] not in have]
|
||
total = len(EVIDENCE_ITEMS)
|
||
pct = round(100.0 * len(present) / total) if total else 0
|
||
return {"pct": pct, "present": present, "missing": missing, "total": total}
|
||
|
||
|
||
# --- Machinery Regulation (2023/1230) applicability — person-safety axis ---
|
||
# A bare control component is not "machinery" itself, but if its function can
|
||
# endanger persons (movement, laser, stored energy …) it is safety-relevant: the
|
||
# duty hits the machine builder, the component maker supplies evidence, and a
|
||
# cyber compromise can defeat a safety function (the CRA × MaschinenVO bridge).
|
||
HAZARD_TYPES = [
|
||
{"key": "movement_crush", "label": "Bewegung / Quetschen"},
|
||
{"key": "laser_radiation", "label": "Laser / Strahlung (Auge)"},
|
||
{"key": "force_energy", "label": "Kraft / gespeicherte Energie"},
|
||
{"key": "temperature", "label": "Temperatur / Hitze"},
|
||
{"key": "electrical", "label": "Elektrische Gefährdung"},
|
||
]
|
||
_HAZARD_KEYS = {h["key"]: h["label"] for h in HAZARD_TYPES}
|
||
|
||
MV_DIREKT = "direkt"
|
||
MV_SICHERHEITSRELEVANT = "sicherheitsrelevant"
|
||
MV_NICHT = "nicht_relevant"
|
||
_MV_LABEL = {
|
||
MV_DIREKT: "Maschinenverordnung direkt betroffen",
|
||
MV_SICHERHEITSRELEVANT: "Sicherheitsrelevante Komponente (indirekt)",
|
||
MV_NICHT: "Maschinenverordnung nicht relevant",
|
||
}
|
||
|
||
|
||
def compute_machinery_verdict(
|
||
producer_type: str = "",
|
||
is_machinery: bool = False,
|
||
safety_relevant: bool = False,
|
||
hazard_types=None,
|
||
is_safety_component: bool = False,
|
||
) -> dict:
|
||
"""3-tier Machinery-Regulation verdict + cyber→safety bridge flag.
|
||
`safety_relevant`: can the function endanger persons on fault OR manipulation?"""
|
||
hazards = [{"key": k, "label": _HAZARD_KEYS[k]} for k in (hazard_types or []) if k in _HAZARD_KEYS]
|
||
direct = bool(is_machinery) or producer_type == MACHINE_INTEGRATOR or bool(is_safety_component)
|
||
reasons: list = []
|
||
if direct:
|
||
tier = MV_DIREKT
|
||
reasons.append("Maschine/Anlage bzw. Sicherheitsbauteil → MaschinenVO-Pflichten direkt.")
|
||
elif safety_relevant or hazards:
|
||
tier = MV_SICHERHEITSRELEVANT
|
||
reasons.append("Komponente, deren Funktion bei Fehler oder Manipulation Personen gefährden kann.")
|
||
reasons.append("MaschinenVO-Pflicht trifft den Maschinenbauer; als Zulieferer liefern Sie Sicherheits-/Cyber-Nachweise zu.")
|
||
else:
|
||
tier = MV_NICHT
|
||
reasons.append("Keine Personengefährdung erkennbar.")
|
||
|
||
bridge = tier in (MV_DIREKT, MV_SICHERHEITSRELEVANT)
|
||
if bridge:
|
||
reasons.append(
|
||
"Cyber-trifft-Safety: Ein Angriff auf die Steuerung kann eine Sicherheitsfunktion aushebeln "
|
||
"(Geschwindigkeit/Position/Verriegelung) → Personenschaden."
|
||
)
|
||
return {
|
||
"tier": tier,
|
||
"label": _MV_LABEL[tier],
|
||
"hazards": hazards,
|
||
"cyber_safety_bridge": bridge,
|
||
"reasons": reasons,
|
||
}
|