Files
breakpilot-compliance/ai-compliance-sdk/internal/iace/pattern_engine_test.go
T
Benjamin Admin f07c4db164 feat(iace): Sprint 3B — Human Interaction Model
- 6 Standard-Rollen: operator, maintenance_tech, programmer, cleaning_staff, bystander, supervisor
- HumanRoles []string Feld in HazardPattern, MatchInput, PatternMatch
- patternMatches() filtert Patterns nach Rolle (nil = feuert fuer alle Rollen)
- MatchReason um human_role Typ erweitert (Explainability)
- 25 bestehende Patterns mit Rollen annotiert:
  - Cobot HP059/062/064 → operator/programmer
  - Maintenance HP700-714 → maintenance_tech/programmer
  - Operational HP070/073-078/080 → operator/maintenance_tech/programmer
- Init + Parser Handler reichen Roles an MatchInput durch
- 4 neue Tests: NilFiresAlways, MaintenanceTechFilter, ProgrammerTeachMode, RoleCount

Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.6 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com>
2026-05-10 08:22:55 +02:00

542 lines
16 KiB
Go

package iace
import "testing"
func TestPatternEngine_RobotArm_MechanicalHazards(t *testing.T) {
engine := NewPatternEngine()
result := engine.Match(MatchInput{
ComponentLibraryIDs: []string{"C001"}, // Roboterarm: moving_part, rotating_part, high_force
EnergySourceIDs: []string{"EN01", "EN02"}, // kinetic translational + rotational
})
if len(result.MatchedPatterns) == 0 {
t.Fatal("expected matched patterns for robot arm + kinetic energy")
}
// Should match mechanical hazard patterns (HP001, HP002, HP006)
hasMechHazard := false
for _, h := range result.SuggestedHazards {
if h.Category == "mechanical_hazard" {
hasMechHazard = true
break
}
}
if !hasMechHazard {
t.Error("expected mechanical_hazard in suggested hazards for robot arm")
}
}
func TestPatternEngine_Schaltschrank_ElectricalHazards(t *testing.T) {
engine := NewPatternEngine()
result := engine.Match(MatchInput{
ComponentLibraryIDs: []string{"C061"}, // Schaltschrank: high_voltage, electrical_part
EnergySourceIDs: []string{"EN04"}, // Elektrische Energie
})
if len(result.MatchedPatterns) == 0 {
t.Fatal("expected matched patterns for control cabinet + electrical energy")
}
hasElecHazard := false
for _, h := range result.SuggestedHazards {
if h.Category == "electrical_hazard" {
hasElecHazard = true
break
}
}
if !hasElecHazard {
t.Error("expected electrical_hazard in suggested hazards for Schaltschrank")
}
}
func TestPatternEngine_SPS_Switch_SoftwareCyberHazards(t *testing.T) {
engine := NewPatternEngine()
result := engine.Match(MatchInput{
ComponentLibraryIDs: []string{"C071", "C111"}, // SPS + Switch: has_software, programmable, networked, it_component
EnergySourceIDs: []string{"EN18"}, // Cyber/Data energy
})
if len(result.MatchedPatterns) == 0 {
t.Fatal("expected matched patterns for SPS + Switch + cyber energy")
}
categories := make(map[string]bool)
for _, h := range result.SuggestedHazards {
categories[h.Category] = true
}
if !categories["software_fault"] {
t.Error("expected software_fault hazard for SPS")
}
if !categories["unauthorized_access"] {
t.Error("expected unauthorized_access hazard for networked components + cyber energy")
}
}
func TestPatternEngine_AIModule_AISpecificHazards(t *testing.T) {
engine := NewPatternEngine()
result := engine.Match(MatchInput{
ComponentLibraryIDs: []string{"C119"}, // KI-Inferenzmodul: has_ai, has_software, networked
EnergySourceIDs: []string{"EN19", "EN18"}, // AI model + cyber energy
})
if len(result.MatchedPatterns) == 0 {
t.Fatal("expected matched patterns for AI inference module")
}
categories := make(map[string]bool)
for _, h := range result.SuggestedHazards {
categories[h.Category] = true
}
if !categories["false_classification"] {
t.Error("expected false_classification hazard for AI module")
}
if !categories["model_drift"] {
t.Error("expected model_drift hazard for AI module")
}
}
func TestPatternEngine_EmptyInput_EmptyResults(t *testing.T) {
engine := NewPatternEngine()
result := engine.Match(MatchInput{})
if len(result.MatchedPatterns) != 0 {
t.Errorf("expected no matched patterns for empty input, got %d", len(result.MatchedPatterns))
}
if len(result.SuggestedHazards) != 0 {
t.Errorf("expected no suggested hazards for empty input, got %d", len(result.SuggestedHazards))
}
}
func TestPatternEngine_ExclusionTags(t *testing.T) {
engine := NewPatternEngine()
// HP029 requires has_software+programmable, excludes has_ai
// C071 (SPS) has has_software+programmable but NOT has_ai → should match HP029
result1 := engine.Match(MatchInput{
ComponentLibraryIDs: []string{"C071"}, // SPS
})
hasHP029 := false
for _, p := range result1.MatchedPatterns {
if p.PatternID == "HP029" {
hasHP029 = true
break
}
}
if !hasHP029 {
t.Error("HP029 should match for SPS (has_software+programmable, no has_ai)")
}
// C119 (KI-Inferenzmodul) has has_ai → HP029 should be excluded
result2 := engine.Match(MatchInput{
ComponentLibraryIDs: []string{"C119"}, // KI-Inferenzmodul: has_ai
})
hasHP029_2 := false
for _, p := range result2.MatchedPatterns {
if p.PatternID == "HP029" {
hasHP029_2 = true
break
}
}
if hasHP029_2 {
t.Error("HP029 should NOT match for AI module (excluded by has_ai tag)")
}
}
func TestPatternEngine_HydraulicPatterns(t *testing.T) {
engine := NewPatternEngine()
result := engine.Match(MatchInput{
ComponentLibraryIDs: []string{"C042"}, // Hydraulikzylinder
EnergySourceIDs: []string{"EN05"}, // Hydraulische Energie
})
hasHydraulicHazard := false
for _, h := range result.SuggestedHazards {
if h.Category == "pneumatic_hydraulic" {
hasHydraulicHazard = true
break
}
}
if !hasHydraulicHazard {
t.Error("expected pneumatic_hydraulic hazard for hydraulic cylinder + hydraulic energy")
}
}
func TestPatternEngine_MeasuresAndEvidence(t *testing.T) {
engine := NewPatternEngine()
result := engine.Match(MatchInput{
ComponentLibraryIDs: []string{"C001"}, // Roboterarm
EnergySourceIDs: []string{"EN01"}, // Kinetische Energie
})
if len(result.SuggestedMeasures) == 0 {
t.Error("expected suggested measures for robot arm")
}
if len(result.SuggestedEvidence) == 0 {
t.Error("expected suggested evidence for robot arm")
}
}
func TestPatternEngine_ResolvedTags(t *testing.T) {
engine := NewPatternEngine()
result := engine.Match(MatchInput{
ComponentLibraryIDs: []string{"C001"},
EnergySourceIDs: []string{"EN01"},
CustomTags: []string{"my_custom_tag"},
})
tagSet := toSet(result.ResolvedTags)
if !tagSet["moving_part"] {
t.Error("expected 'moving_part' in resolved tags")
}
if !tagSet["kinetic"] {
t.Error("expected 'kinetic' in resolved tags")
}
if !tagSet["my_custom_tag"] {
t.Error("expected 'my_custom_tag' in resolved tags")
}
}
func TestPatternEngine_SafetyDevice_HighPriority(t *testing.T) {
engine := NewPatternEngine()
result := engine.Match(MatchInput{
ComponentLibraryIDs: []string{"C101"}, // Not-Halt-Taster: safety_device, emergency_stop
})
hasSafetyFail := false
for _, h := range result.SuggestedHazards {
if h.Category == "safety_function_failure" {
hasSafetyFail = true
break
}
}
if !hasSafetyFail {
t.Error("expected safety_function_failure for Not-Halt-Taster")
}
}
// ── Operational State Graph tests ──────────────────────────────────
func TestPatternEngine_OperationalState_NilFiresAlways(t *testing.T) {
// Patterns with nil OperationalStates should fire regardless of input states
engine := NewPatternEngine()
result1 := engine.Match(MatchInput{
ComponentLibraryIDs: []string{"C001"},
EnergySourceIDs: []string{"EN01"},
})
result2 := engine.Match(MatchInput{
ComponentLibraryIDs: []string{"C001"},
EnergySourceIDs: []string{"EN01"},
OperationalStates: []string{"automatic_operation"},
})
if len(result1.MatchedPatterns) == 0 {
t.Fatal("expected patterns to fire without operational states")
}
if len(result2.MatchedPatterns) == 0 {
t.Fatal("expected patterns to fire with automatic_operation state")
}
// nil-state patterns should fire in both cases
if len(result1.MatchedPatterns) != len(result2.MatchedPatterns) {
t.Logf("patterns without states: %d, with automatic_operation: %d", len(result1.MatchedPatterns), len(result2.MatchedPatterns))
// This is OK — some patterns may have OperationalStates set and filter differently
}
}
func TestPatternEngine_OperationalState_MaintenanceFilter(t *testing.T) {
// HP073 (LOTO) has OperationalStates: ["maintenance"]
// It should only fire when maintenance is in the input states
engine := NewPatternEngine()
// Without maintenance state — HP073 should still fire if no states in input
// (because empty input states = no filtering)
resultNoState := engine.Match(MatchInput{
ComponentLibraryIDs: []string{"C001"},
EnergySourceIDs: []string{"EN01"},
LifecyclePhases: []string{"maintenance"},
})
// With maintenance state — HP073 should fire
resultMaint := engine.Match(MatchInput{
ComponentLibraryIDs: []string{"C001"},
EnergySourceIDs: []string{"EN01"},
LifecyclePhases: []string{"maintenance"},
OperationalStates: []string{"maintenance"},
})
// With only automatic_operation — HP073 should NOT fire
resultAuto := engine.Match(MatchInput{
ComponentLibraryIDs: []string{"C001"},
EnergySourceIDs: []string{"EN01"},
LifecyclePhases: []string{"maintenance"},
OperationalStates: []string{"automatic_operation"},
})
// HP073 should be in resultMaint but not in resultAuto
hasHP073Maint := false
for _, p := range resultMaint.MatchedPatterns {
if p.PatternID == "HP073" {
hasHP073Maint = true
break
}
}
hasHP073Auto := false
for _, p := range resultAuto.MatchedPatterns {
if p.PatternID == "HP073" {
hasHP073Auto = true
break
}
}
if !hasHP073Maint {
t.Error("HP073 should fire with maintenance operational state")
}
if hasHP073Auto {
t.Error("HP073 should NOT fire with automatic_operation operational state")
}
_ = resultNoState // HP073 fires here too because empty input states = no filter
}
func TestPatternEngine_StateTransition_UnexpectedRestart(t *testing.T) {
// HP068 has StateTransitions: ["maintenance→automatic_operation", "emergency_stop→recovery_mode"]
engine := NewPatternEngine()
// HP068 requires moving_part + programmable — C001 (Roboterarm) + C071 (SPS)
// With matching transition
resultMatch := engine.Match(MatchInput{
ComponentLibraryIDs: []string{"C001", "C071"},
EnergySourceIDs: []string{"EN01"},
LifecyclePhases: []string{"fault_clearing"},
OperationalStates: []string{"recovery_mode", "emergency_stop"},
StateTransitions: []string{"maintenance→automatic_operation"},
})
// With non-matching transition
resultNoMatch := engine.Match(MatchInput{
ComponentLibraryIDs: []string{"C001", "C071"},
EnergySourceIDs: []string{"EN01"},
LifecyclePhases: []string{"fault_clearing"},
OperationalStates: []string{"recovery_mode", "emergency_stop"},
StateTransitions: []string{"startup→homing"},
})
hasHP068Match := false
for _, p := range resultMatch.MatchedPatterns {
if p.PatternID == "HP068" {
hasHP068Match = true
// Verify explainability reasons include state transition
hasTransReason := false
for _, r := range p.MatchReasons {
if r.Type == "state_transition" {
hasTransReason = true
break
}
}
if !hasTransReason {
t.Error("HP068 match should include state_transition reason")
}
break
}
}
hasHP068NoMatch := false
for _, p := range resultNoMatch.MatchedPatterns {
if p.PatternID == "HP068" {
hasHP068NoMatch = true
break
}
}
if !hasHP068Match {
t.Error("HP068 should fire with matching state transition")
}
if hasHP068NoMatch {
t.Error("HP068 should NOT fire with non-matching state transition")
}
}
func TestPatternEngine_MatchReasons_IncludeOperationalState(t *testing.T) {
// Verify that MatchReasons include operational_state entries
engine := NewPatternEngine()
result := engine.Match(MatchInput{
ComponentLibraryIDs: []string{"C001"},
EnergySourceIDs: []string{"EN01"},
LifecyclePhases: []string{"maintenance"},
OperationalStates: []string{"maintenance"},
})
for _, p := range result.MatchedPatterns {
if p.PatternID == "HP073" {
hasStateReason := false
for _, r := range p.MatchReasons {
if r.Type == "operational_state" && r.Tag == "maintenance" && r.Met {
hasStateReason = true
break
}
}
if !hasStateReason {
t.Error("HP073 MatchReasons should include operational_state:maintenance with Met=true")
}
return
}
}
t.Error("HP073 not found in matched patterns")
}
func TestAllOperationalStates_Count(t *testing.T) {
states := AllOperationalStates()
if len(states) != 9 {
t.Errorf("expected 9 operational states, got %d", len(states))
}
}
func TestStandardStateTransitions_Valid(t *testing.T) {
transitions := StandardStateTransitions()
if len(transitions) < 15 {
t.Errorf("expected at least 15 state transitions, got %d", len(transitions))
}
// Verify all transitions reference valid states
stateSet := make(map[string]bool)
for _, s := range AllOperationalStates() {
stateSet[s] = true
}
for _, tr := range transitions {
// Format: "from→to" (→ is multi-byte UTF-8)
parts := splitTransition(tr)
if len(parts) != 2 {
t.Errorf("invalid transition format: %q", tr)
continue
}
if !stateSet[parts[0]] {
t.Errorf("transition %q references unknown state: %q", tr, parts[0])
}
if !stateSet[parts[1]] {
t.Errorf("transition %q references unknown state: %q", tr, parts[1])
}
}
}
// ── Human Interaction Model tests ──────────────────────────────────
func TestPatternEngine_HumanRole_NilFiresAlways(t *testing.T) {
engine := NewPatternEngine()
result1 := engine.Match(MatchInput{
ComponentLibraryIDs: []string{"C001"},
EnergySourceIDs: []string{"EN01"},
})
result2 := engine.Match(MatchInput{
ComponentLibraryIDs: []string{"C001"},
EnergySourceIDs: []string{"EN01"},
HumanRoles: []string{"operator"},
})
if len(result1.MatchedPatterns) == 0 {
t.Fatal("expected patterns without roles")
}
if len(result2.MatchedPatterns) == 0 {
t.Fatal("expected patterns with operator role")
}
}
func TestPatternEngine_HumanRole_MaintenanceTechFilter(t *testing.T) {
// HP073 has HumanRoles: ["maintenance_tech"]
engine := NewPatternEngine()
// With maintenance_tech → HP073 should fire
resultMT := engine.Match(MatchInput{
ComponentLibraryIDs: []string{"C001"},
EnergySourceIDs: []string{"EN01"},
LifecyclePhases: []string{"maintenance"},
OperationalStates: []string{"maintenance"},
HumanRoles: []string{"maintenance_tech"},
})
// With only operator → HP073 should NOT fire
resultOp := engine.Match(MatchInput{
ComponentLibraryIDs: []string{"C001"},
EnergySourceIDs: []string{"EN01"},
LifecyclePhases: []string{"maintenance"},
OperationalStates: []string{"maintenance"},
HumanRoles: []string{"operator"},
})
hasHP073MT := false
for _, p := range resultMT.MatchedPatterns {
if p.PatternID == "HP073" {
hasHP073MT = true
break
}
}
hasHP073Op := false
for _, p := range resultOp.MatchedPatterns {
if p.PatternID == "HP073" {
hasHP073Op = true
break
}
}
if !hasHP073MT {
t.Error("HP073 should fire for maintenance_tech role")
}
if hasHP073Op {
t.Error("HP073 should NOT fire for operator role")
}
}
func TestPatternEngine_HumanRole_ProgrammerTeachMode(t *testing.T) {
// HP062 has OperationalStates: ["teach_mode"], HumanRoles: ["programmer"]
engine := NewPatternEngine()
// Programmer in teach mode with cobot components
result := engine.Match(MatchInput{
ComponentLibraryIDs: []string{"C139"}, // Cobot: moving_part, programmable, collaborative_operation
EnergySourceIDs: []string{"EN01"},
OperationalStates: []string{"teach_mode"},
HumanRoles: []string{"programmer"},
})
hasHP062 := false
for _, p := range result.MatchedPatterns {
if p.PatternID == "HP062" {
hasHP062 = true
// Verify explainability
hasRoleReason := false
for _, r := range p.MatchReasons {
if r.Type == "human_role" && r.Tag == "programmer" && r.Met {
hasRoleReason = true
break
}
}
if !hasRoleReason {
t.Error("HP062 should include human_role:programmer reason")
}
break
}
}
if !hasHP062 {
t.Error("HP062 should fire for programmer in teach_mode with cobot")
}
}
func TestAllHumanRoles_Count(t *testing.T) {
roles := AllHumanRoles()
if len(roles) != 6 {
t.Errorf("expected 6 human roles, got %d", len(roles))
}
}
func splitTransition(tr string) []string {
// Split on → (UTF-8: 0xE2 0x86 0x92)
idx := 0
for i := 0; i < len(tr); i++ {
if tr[i] == 0xE2 && i+2 < len(tr) && tr[i+1] == 0x86 && tr[i+2] == 0x92 {
return []string{tr[:i], tr[i+3:]}
}
idx = i
}
_ = idx
return []string{tr}
}