Registry filled proposed_obligation_id for the 3 NIST primary_implementation
controls: SI-7->signed_update_integrity, SI-2->provide_security_updates,
CM-7->remote_access_attack_surface_min. Adopted onto cra_nist.jsonl so the join
is now EXACT (obligation_id) instead of the coarse citation_unit fallback.
obligation-status now surfaces SI-2 under provide_security_updates; test extended.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.7 <noreply@anthropic.com>
CRA Annex I Part I (2)(e)/(2)(l)/(2)(i) had no clean OWASP target (rejected:
"Mapping ueber NIST/BSI erforderlich"). Their NIST home, curated + accepted:
(2)(e) Integritaet -> SI-7 (Software/Firmware/Information Integrity)
(2)(l) Sichere Updates -> SI-2 (Flaw Remediation)
(2)(i) Angriffsflaeche -> CM-7 (Least Functionality)
New mapping_type=primary_implementation = the single canonical control per
obligation (stronger than implements/supports); related controls (SC-3(3),
RA-5, AC-6, SI-16, ...) follow later as supports.
Evidence is framework-AGNOSTIC: SI-7/SI-2/CM-7 reuse the shared evidence_type
catalog (config_export/test_report/repo_scan) - same types carry CRA, NIST,
ISO 27001, IEC 62443, BSI. (framework,control) is only the link, not the type.
obligation_id left empty: the Obligation Registry assigns it (exported via
controls_for_obligation_mapping.json), then we adopt. go test ./internal/ucca green.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.7 <noreply@anthropic.com>
The Obligation Registry filled proposed_obligation_id (7/7) + cut the logging
family (obligations 47->66). Adopted obligation_id onto our 7 accepted CRA->OWASP
mappings; the join now prefers the EXACT obligation_id over the coarse
citation_unit (which stays as fallback for not-yet-adopted rows).
Effect: semantic coverage 2->4 (user_authentication_required,
credential_confidentiality_protection, auth_key_management,
event_logging_security_events). Befund 1 resolved: V11.2.1 crypto now sits under
credential_confidentiality_protection, not user_authentication_required.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.7 <noreply@anthropic.com>
7 accepted, 13 rejected (reviewed_by=benjamin, 2026-06-25). The accepted set is
the first audited ground truth of the compliance graph:
(2c) Zugriff -> V6.3.1, V6.1.1 (Auth)
(2d) Crypto -> V11.2.1, V11.7.1 (corrected from the retriever's wrong V14)
(2k) Logging -> V16.3.3, V16.3.4, V16.1.1
Rejected stay as audit trail. (2e) integrity, (2l) updates, (2i) attack surface
rejected with reason "OWASP ASVS not the right target standard, map via NIST/BSI"
— architectural proof for the multi-framework framework_* layer.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.7 <noreply@anthropic.com>
- DROP confidence from the persisted mapping: a curated mapping is a
professional statement, not an AI guess (retriever score -> rationale only).
- ADD mapping_status (candidate|accepted|rejected|superseded) — the review state.
- ADD audit trail (reviewed_by/review_date/review_reason); accepted/rejected
fail-closed without it.
- EXTEND mapping_type: + implements, + contradicts.
- Advisor truth = mapping_status=accepted (acceptedOnly filter).
- migrate the 18 CRA->OWASP rows to mapping_status=candidate.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.7 <noreply@anthropic.com>
18 retriever_candidate mappings generated via the sdk-dev control-intent
retriever. All marked retriever_candidate (NOT curated truth) — the review
step turns the good ones into human_curated.
Empirical validation of the A-decision: the retriever proposes, but produces
wrong candidates (e.g. encryption -> V14 Config instead of V11 Crypto;
V14.2.4 over-appears) that only human review catches. Review notes inline.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.7 <noreply@anthropic.com>
Versioned JSONL store + Go model for Regulation->Control mappings, per the
A-decision: the retriever only PROPOSES candidates; the curated mapping is the
audited truth the Advisor uses at runtime, never re-invented per query.
- ControlMapping struct (source_norm/source_role/target_framework/target_control/
mapping_type/confidence/provenance/rationale/version)
- enum validation (rule layer), fail-closed loader, forward+reverse index,
curated-only filter (IsCurated)
- seed: 2 retriever_candidate rows CRA Annex I -> OWASP ASVS (not yet curated)
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.7 <noreply@anthropic.com>
Benjamin Admin