feat(iace): risk as confidence range + label in benchmark tab

Report the tool's risk number as a plausible range with a confidence
label instead of a false-precision point value (confidence-aware
tonality — the assessment is confirmed by the DSB / safety expert).

- risk_estimation.go: EstimateConfidence (hoch/mittel/niedrig from how the
  contact mode resolved), EstimateRiskRange (S±1 and aggregate L=F+W+P ±1,
  the empirically validated per-parameter accuracy), RiskLevelRange; share
  the riskBandLabel thresholds with EstimateRiskLevel.
- risk_benchmark.go: RiskComparisonPair gains eng_risk_point/low/high +
  level + level_range + confidence; RiskAgreement gains high_confidence_pct.
- RiskComparison.tsx: per-hazard range "low–high (level range)" + point,
  confidence chip, and an aggregate confidence line; types in useBenchmark.ts.
- Unit tests for the range/confidence helpers.

Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.8 <noreply@anthropic.com>
This commit is contained in:
Benjamin Admin
2026-06-10 23:04:56 +02:00
parent 97575cc9c0
commit a7dc12f30f
5 changed files with 225 additions and 37 deletions
@@ -203,16 +203,92 @@ func EstimateRiskLevel(s, f, w, p int) (int, string) {
s = 1
}
idx := s * (f + w + p)
return idx, riskBandLabel(idx)
}
// riskBandLabel maps a risk index (3..75) to BreakPilot's German level band.
// Single source of truth for the thresholds, shared by EstimateRiskLevel and
// the confidence-range derivation.
func riskBandLabel(idx int) string {
switch {
case idx >= 45:
return idx, "kritisch"
return "kritisch"
case idx >= 30:
return idx, "hoch"
return "hoch"
case idx >= 18:
return idx, "mittel"
return "mittel"
case idx >= 9:
return idx, "gering"
return "gering"
default:
return idx, "vernachlaessigbar"
return "vernachlaessigbar"
}
}
func clampRisk1to5(x int) int {
if x < 1 {
return 1
}
if x > 5 {
return 5
}
return x
}
// EstimateConfidence reports how well-anchored the tool's risk parameters are,
// from HOW the injury mechanism (contact mode) was resolved: an explicit
// scenario keyword → "hoch" (strong kinematic signal), a category fallback →
// "mittel", nothing → "niedrig" (parameters fell back to neutral). This is an
// honest signal that the point estimate is a heuristic, not a guarantee — the
// final assessment stays with the DSB / safety expert.
func EstimateConfidence(cats []string, scenario string) string {
text := normalizeDE(scenario)
for _, e := range contactModeKeywords {
for _, kw := range e.keywords {
if strings.Contains(text, kw) {
return "hoch"
}
}
}
for _, c := range cats {
if _, ok := categoryDefaultMode[c]; ok {
return "mittel"
}
}
return "niedrig"
}
// EstimateRiskRange returns the point risk index plus a plausible low/high band.
// The band shifts severity S by ±1 and the aggregate likelihood L = F+W+P by ±1
// (each within its domain). We move L as a whole rather than each of F/W/P
// independently because the validation shows the per-parameter errors largely
// cancel in the sum (W is within ±1 of the GT ~100% of the time). The result
// communicates that the risk number is an ESTIMATE with uncertainty rather than
// a false-precision point value — aligned with the confidence-aware tonality.
func EstimateRiskRange(s, f, w, p int) (low, point, high int) {
s = clampRisk1to5(s)
l := clampRisk1to5(f) + clampRisk1to5(w) + clampRisk1to5(p) // 3..15
clampL := func(x int) int {
if x < 3 {
return 3
}
if x > 15 {
return 15
}
return x
}
point = s * l
low = clampRisk1to5(s-1) * clampL(l-1)
high = clampRisk1to5(s+1) * clampL(l+1)
return low, point, high
}
// RiskLevelRange returns the German level band for the point plus a combined
// "lowhigh" range label (single label when low and high fall in the same band).
func RiskLevelRange(low, point, high int) (level, levelRange string) {
level = riskBandLabel(point)
ll, lh := riskBandLabel(low), riskBandLabel(high)
if ll == lh {
return level, ll
}
return level, ll + "" + lh // en dash
}